Performative Power

by   Moritz Hardt, et al.

We introduce the notion of performative power, which measures the ability of a firm operating an algorithmic system, such as a digital content recommendation platform, to steer a population. We relate performative power to the economic theory of market power. Traditional economic concepts are well known to struggle with identifying anti-competitive patterns in digital platforms–a core challenge is the difficulty of defining the market, its participants, products, and prices. Performative power sidesteps the problem of market definition by focusing on a directly observable statistical measure instead. High performative power enables a platform to profit from steering participant behavior, whereas low performative power ensures that learning from historical data is close to optimal. Our first general result shows that under low performative power, a firm cannot do better than standard supervised learning on observed data. We draw an analogy with a firm being a price-taker, an economic condition that arises under perfect competition in classical market models. We then contrast this with a market where performative power is concentrated and show that the equilibrium state can differ significantly. We go on to study performative power in a concrete setting of strategic classification where participants can switch between competing firms. We show that monopolies maximize performative power and disutility for the participant, while competition and outside options decrease performative power. We end on a discussion of connections to measures of market power in economics and of the relationship with ongoing antitrust debates.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Econometric Modeling of Intraday Electricity Market Price with Inadequate Historical Data

The intraday (ID) electricity market has received an increasing attentio...

Competition, Alignment, and Equilibria in Digital Marketplaces

Competition between traditional platforms is known to improve user utili...

A Holistic Approach to Forecasting Wholesale Energy Market Prices

Electricity market price predictions enable energy market participants t...

Using Reinforcement Learning to Study Platform Economies under Market Shocks

Driven by rapid digitization and expansive internet access, market-drive...

Statistical estimation of superhedging prices

We consider statistical estimation of superhedging prices using historic...

Cryptoart: Ethical Challenges of the NFT Revolution

The digital transformation of the art world has become a revolution for ...

Decongestion by Representation: Learning to Improve Economic Welfare in Marketplaces

Congestion is a common failure mode of markets, where consumers compete ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset