Seeing the forest for the trees? An investigation of network knowledge

by   Emily Breza, et al.

This paper assesses the empirical content of one of the most prevalent assumptions in the economics of networks literature, namely the assumption that decision makers have full knowledge about the networks they interact on. Using network data from 75 villages, we ask 4,554 individuals to assess whether five randomly chosen pairs of households in their village are linked through financial, social, and informational relationships. We find that network knowledge is low and highly localized, declining steeply with the pair's network distance to the respondent. 46 offer a guess about the status of a potential link between a given pair of individuals. Even when willing to offer a guess, respondents can only correctly identify the links 37 the social distance to the pair corresponds to a 10pp increase in the probability of misidentifying the link. We then investigate the theoretical implications of this assumption by showing that the predictions of various models change substantially if agents behave under the more realistic assumption of incomplete knowledge about the network. Taken together, our results suggest that the assumption of full network knowledge (i) may serve as a poor approximation to the real world and (ii) is not innocuous: allowing for incomplete network knowledge may have first-order implications for a range of qualitative and quantitative results in various contexts.


How does information affect asymmetric congestion games?

We study traffic networks with multiple origin-destination pairs, relaxi...

Modelling community formation driven by the status of individual in a society

In human societies, people's willingness to compete and strive for bette...

Popularity is linked to neural coordination: Neural evidence for an Anna Karenina principle in social networks

People differ in how they attend to, interpret, and respond to their sur...

Resource Availability in the Social Cloud: An Economics Perspective

This paper focuses on social cloud formation, where agents are involved ...

The open access effect in social media exposure of scholarly articles: A matched-pair analysis

Scholarly journals are increasingly using social media to share their la...

Plasticity as a link between spatially explicit, distance-independent, and whole-stand forest growth models

Models at various levels of resolution are commonly used, both for fores...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset