The Efficiency of Best-Response Dynamics

by   Michal Feldman, et al.

Best response (BR) dynamics is a natural method by which players proceed toward a pure Nash equilibrium via a local search method. The quality of the equilibrium reached may depend heavily on the order by which players are chosen to perform their best response moves. A deviator ruleS is a method for selecting the next deviating player. We provide a measure for quantifying the performance of different deviator rules. The inefficiency of a deviator rule S is the maximum ratio, over all initial profiles p, between the social cost of the worst equilibrium reachable by S from p and the social cost of the best equilibrium reachable from p. This inefficiency always lies between 1 and the price of anarchy. We study the inefficiency of various deviator rules in network formation games and job scheduling games (both are congestion games, where BR dynamics always converges to a pure NE). For some classes of games, we compute optimal deviator rules. Furthermore, we define and study a new class of deviator rules, called local deviator rules. Such rules choose the next deviator as a function of a restricted set of parameters, and satisfy a natural condition called independence of irrelevant players. We present upper bounds on the inefficiency of some local deviator rules, and also show that for some classes of games, no local deviator rule can guarantee inefficiency lower than the price of anarchy.


page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4


Simultaneous Contests with Equal Sharing Allocation of Prizes: Computational Complexity and Price of Anarchy

We study a general scenario of simultaneous contests that allocate prize...

The Impact of Tribalism on Social Welfare

We explore the impact of mutual altruism among the players belonging to ...

Game Connectivity and Adaptive Dynamics

We analyse the typical structure of games in terms of the connectivity p...

Network Creation Games with Local Information and Edge Swaps

In the swap game (SG) selfish players, each of which is associated to a ...

Shapley Facility Location Games

Facility location games have been a topic of major interest in economics...

The Communication Complexity of Local Search

We study the following communication variant of local search. There is s...

Bounded rationality for relaxing best response and mutual consistency: An information-theoretic model of partial self-reference

While game theory has been transformative for decision-making, the assum...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset