Inference in Experiments with Matched Pairs and Imperfect Compliance
share
This paper studies inference for the local average treatment effect in randomized controlled trials with imperfect compliance where treatment status is determined according to "matched pairs." By "matched pairs," we mean that units are sampled i.i.d. from the population of interest, paired according to observed, baseline covariates and finally, within each pair, one unit is selected at random for treatment. Under weak assumptions governing the quality of the pairings, we first derive the limiting behavior of the usual Wald (i.e., two-stage least squares) estimator of the local average treatment effect. We show further that the conventional heteroskedasticity-robust estimator of its limiting variance is generally conservative in that its limit in probability is (typically strictly) larger than the limiting variance. We therefore provide an alternative estimator of the limiting variance that is consistent for the desired quantity. Finally, we consider the use of additional observed, baseline covariates not used in pairing units to increase the precision with which we can estimate the local average treatment effect. To this end, we derive the limiting behavior of a two-stage least squares estimator of the local average treatment effect which includes both the additional covariates in addition to pair fixed effects, and show that the limiting variance is always less than or equal to that of the Wald estimator. To complete our analysis, we provide a consistent estimator of this limiting variance. A simulation study confirms the practical relevance of our theoretical results. We use our results to revisit a prominent experiment studying the effect of macroinsurance on microenterprise in Egypt.
READ FULL TEXT