MetaMetaZipf. What do analyses of city size distributions have in common?

by   Clémentine Cottineau, et al.

In this article, I conduct a textual and contextual analysis of the empirical literature on Zipf's law for cities. Building on previous meta-analysis material openly available, I collect full texts and bibliographies of 66 scientific articles published in English and construct similarity networks of the terms they use as well as of the references and disciplines they cite. I use these networks as explanatory variables in a model of the similarity network of the distribution of Zipf estimates reported in the 66 articles. I find that the proximity in words frequently used by authors correlates positively with their tendency to report similar values and dispersion of Zipf estimates. The reference framework of articles also plays a role, as articles which cite similar references tend to report similar average values of Zipf estimates. As a complement to previous meta-analyses, the present approach sheds light on the scientific text and context mobilized to report on city size distributions. It allows to identified gaps in the corpus and potentially overlooked articles.


page 4

page 5

page 6

page 13

page 22

page 24


Characterizing in-text citations in scientific articles: A large-scale analysis

We report characteristics of in-text citations in over five million full...

Improper legitimization of hijacked journals through citations

The goal is to study the prevalence of citajacked papers: papers in auth...

Mapping the backbone of the Humanities through the eyes of Wikipedia

The present study aims to establish a valid method by which to apply the...

Learning to Rank Scientific Documents from the Crowd

Finding related published articles is an important task in any science, ...

Structured references from PDF articles: assessing the tools for bibliographic reference extraction and parsing

Many solutions have been provided to extract bibliographic references fr...

Sleeping beauties and temporal evolution of the coronavirus literature

Temporal evolution of the coronavirus literature over the last thirty ye...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset