Nonverbal Robot Feedback for Human Teachers

by   Sandy H. Huang, et al.

Robots can learn preferences from human demonstrations, but their success depends on how informative these demonstrations are. Being informative is unfortunately very challenging, because during teaching, people typically get no transparency into what the robot already knows or has learned so far. In contrast, human students naturally provide a wealth of nonverbal feedback that reveals their level of understanding and engagement. In this work, we study how a robot can similarly provide feedback that is minimally disruptive, yet gives human teachers a better mental model of the robot learner, and thus enables them to teach more effectively. Our idea is that at any point, the robot can indicate what it thinks the correct next action is, shedding light on its current estimate of the human's preferences. We analyze how useful this feedback is, both in theory and with two user studies—one with a virtual character that tests the feedback itself, and one with a PR2 robot that uses gaze as the feedback mechanism. We find that feedback can be useful for improving both the quality of teaching and teachers' understanding of the robot's capability.


page 2

page 13


Understanding Teacher Gaze Patterns for Robot Learning

Human gaze is known to be a strong indicator of underlying human intenti...

Reasoning about Counterfactuals to Improve Human Inverse Reinforcement Learning

To collaborate well with robots, we must be able to understand their dec...

Exploring Implicit Human Responses to Robot Mistakes in a Learning from Demonstration Task

As robots enter human environments, they will be expected to accomplish ...

Wrapping Haptic Displays Around Robot Arms to Communicate Learning

Humans can leverage physical interaction to teach robot arms. As the hum...

Interactive Learning from Policy-Dependent Human Feedback

For agents and robots to become more useful, they must be able to quickl...

User-centered Feedback Design in Person-following Robots for Older Adults

Feedback design is an important aspect of person-following robots for ol...

Equal Affection or Random Selection: the Quality of Subjective Feedback from a Group Perspective

In the setting where a group of agents is asked a single subjective mult...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset