One Instrument to Rule Them All: The Bias and Coverage of Just-ID IV

10/20/2021
by   Joshua Angrist, et al.
0

Two-stage least squares estimates in heavily over-identified instrumental variables (IV) models can be misleadingly close to the corresponding ordinary least squares (OLS) estimates when many instruments are weak. Just-identified (just-ID) IV estimates using a single instrument are also biased, but the importance of weak-instrument bias in just-ID IV applications remains contentious. We argue that in microeconometric applications, just-ID IV estimators can typically be treated as all but unbiased and that the usual inference strategies are likely to be adequate. The argument begins with contour plots for confidence interval coverage as a function of instrument strength and explanatory variable endogeneity. These show undercoverage in excess of 5 estimates differ by an order of magnitude. Three widely-cited microeconometric applications are used to explain why endogeneity is likely low enough for IV estimates to be reliable. We then show that an estimator that's unbiased given a population first-stage sign restriction has bias exceeding that of IV when the restriction is imposed on the data. But screening on the sign of the estimated first stage is shown to halve the median bias of conventional IV without reducing coverage. To the extent that sign-screening is already part of empirical workflows, reported IV estimates enjoy the minimal bias of sign-screened just-ID IV.

READ FULL TEXT

page 1

page 2

page 3

page 4

research
12/09/2022

The Falsification Adaptive Set in Linear Models with Instrumental Variables that Violate the Exogeneity or Exclusion Restriction

For the classical linear model with an endogenous variable estimated by ...
research
08/08/2021

Improving Inference from Simple Instruments through Compliance Estimation

Instrumental variables (IV) regression is widely used to estimate causal...
research
03/20/2023

How Much Should We Trust Instrumental Variable Estimates in Political Science? Practical Advice Based on Over 60 Replicated Studies

Instrumental variable (IV) strategies are widely used in political scien...
research
11/20/2019

Instrumental Variables: to Strengthen or not to Strengthen?

Instrumental variables (IV) are extensively used to estimate treatment e...
research
07/03/2019

Evaluating A Key Instrumental Variable Assumption Using Randomization Tests

Instrumental variable (IV) analyses are becoming common in health servic...
research
10/27/2019

Dual IV: A Single Stage Instrumental Variable Regression

We present a novel single-stage procedure for instrumental variable (IV)...
research
10/02/2019

Quantifying Voter Biases in Online Platforms: An Instrumental Variable Approach

In content-based online platforms, use of aggregate user feedback (say, ...

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset